PM Transcripts

Transcripts from the Prime Ministers of Australia

Howard, John

Period of Service: 11/03/1996 - 03/12/2007
Release Date:
06/04/1999
Release Type:
Interview
Transcript ID:
11190
Released by:
  • Howard, John Winston
TRANSCRIPT OF THE PRIME MINISTER THE HON JOHN HOWARD MP PRESS CONFERENCE - PARLIAMENT HOUSE

E&OE....................................................................................................

Ladies and gentlemen, I've called this news conference with Mr

Ruddock to announce to announce a number of decisions that the Government

has taken today in response to the appalling human tragedy that is

unfolding in Europe particularly in the wake of the forced expulsion

as an act of racial persecution by the forces of President Milosevic

of hundreds of thousands of Albanians who are now trapped in a most

distressing human situation. There are some varying estimates but

there's not much doubt that we are talking about 300,000 to 400,000

people at the very least who have been displaced from their homes.

It is a humanitarian crisis of immense proportions and one that is

likely to get a lot worse.

Australia geographically, of course, is a long way from Yugoslavia

but the Government does not believe that in the circumstances it would

be appropriate for Australia to rely on geographic distance as an

excuse for not doing more. We have already announced a contribution

of $2 million to humanitarian organisations working in the region

including to the United Nations High Commission for Refugees, CARE

Australia, the Red Cross and World Vision. The Cabinet has decided

today to increase that contribution by another $4 million to a total

of $6 million and the assistance will go towards meeting the urgent

relief needs of displaced people in Albania, Macedonia and other surrounding

countries.

But more importantly the Government has decided that Australia should

play its role in the international effort to relieve the burden on

neighbouring states and we have decided to provide within Australia's

safe haven for up to 4,000 people displaced from Kosovo on a temporary

basis until the situation on the ground improves. It will be for an

initial period of three months depending – and that'll be

renewable – depending on the circumstances as they unfold in

Kosovo. I do want to emphasise that this is a purely temporary measure.

Our main aim must be to see these people returned to their homes,

their villages and hamlets in Kosovo as soon as possible.

This decision by the Government is taken as a special measure. It

is to be seen as separate and apart from the normal immigration and

refugee programme. It is conditional on one very important consideration

and that is the passage of legislation by the Federal Parliament with

effect from today, establishing a situation where none of the 4,000

people will be able to initiate any action within Australia for a

change of status. They will not be entitled to seek while in Australia

any change of status. The intention is that they will be provided

with accommodation, with food, the basic necessities of life and health

care. In the nature of an emergency operation such as this it would

be necessary for these people to be received and looked after in perhaps

some defence installations. We have already initiated an urgent assessment

of available temporary accommodation and we are, of course, willing

to naturally bear the full cost of bringing people to Australia. They

are to be here as a special category of displaced people with the

intention that they should return. The passage of that legislation

is a pre-condition or an agreement for the passage of the legislation

rather it is a condition of the implementation of decision.

I have spoken to Mr Beazley the Leader of the Opposition this afternoon.

He has indicated strong support for the Government's decision

and an in-principle commitment to support the passage of the legislation

through the Federal Parliament. I welcome that expression of support

from Mr Beazley. Humanitarian responses of this kind ought as far

as possible to be conducted on a bi-partisan basis.

I want to emphasise to you, ladies and gentlemen, that this is a humanitarian

disaster, a human tragedy beyond the normal tragedies and developments

to which we have almost become numbed over the years. The movement

of populations is the greatest, I understand, in the experience of

Europe since World War II. The behaviour of the Milosevic forces which

have engaged in acts of racial persecution are quite unacceptable.

The Government believes that despite the fact that we are not part

of NATO and we are not involved in any way, of course, with the military

action that we do have a responsibility on humanitarian grounds to

participate in the relief of suffering of such a magnitude.

Australia has a very long and proud record of providing a humanitarian

response to the mass uprooting and movements of populations around

the world and this is very much of a peace with those responses. It

is the sort of response that I believe the Australian public expects

of its Government but more importantly than that it is the right response

because this is a terrible tragedy and even though it is a long way

from Australia we have to play our part.

JOURNALIST:

[inaudible].. what's changed the Government's thinking?

PRIME MINISTER:

Well let me something. Mr Ruddock will no doubt say something about

that as well. But what Mr Ruddock said yesterday was utterly consistent

with the Government's immigration policy. And indeed one matter

that I did not mention was to reconfirm that Mr Ruddock's earlier

indication that in recognition of the grave situation on the ground

Australia is prepared to extend the visas of the estimated 2,000 visitors

from the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia on a case by case basis. What

Mr Ruddock said yesterday was utterly consistent with the Government's

position and policy. This is a special response to a particular situation

which should be seen separately and apart from, and in addition to,

the normal refugee and humanitarian response programme.

JOURNALIST:

[inaudible].Mr Ruddock said they would not go back after the temporary

status.

PRIME MINISTER:

I beg your pardon.

JOURNALIST:

Mr Ruddock argued that people on temporary status were unlikely to

go back.

PRIME MINISTER:

Well I haven't read every single thing Mr Ruddock has said and

Mr Ruddock will no doubt speak for himself. But what is important

is that the Cabinet has looked at this whole situation and has decided,

quite properly in my view, that a special response in all of the circumstances

is needed. Now everything that Mr Ruddock said in relation to the

normal operation of the immigration programme was utterly consistent

with Government policy. And I completely endorse in every way his

handling of the situation. We had a discussion about it, we thought

about it long and hard, and we decided that this was the right thing

to do. Now if you want to spend the next half an hour asking me questions

about what Mr Ruddock said, or thought, or I did before today, well

you go ahead. But I tell you what, I won't be here to answer

them because I think the quality of the decision and the appropriateness

of the decision that had been taken is the right thing.

JOURNALIST:

Can I just ask, how are these people physically going to get here?

Are Australian RAAF planes going to be involved, and how soon do you

expect the first people to arrive?

PRIME MINISTER:

Well Tony, I can only say in response to that that people are working

away furiously now to make those arrangements. I can't answer

all of that now. Just a moment Aban. I can't answer that. All

I can say to you is that we've taken this decision, I've

outlined the basis of the decision. We've now asked all of our

advisers to prepare a detailed game plan. Clearly there will be, I

imagine, involved the chartering of aircraft, the use of all available

aircraft. We've got to work out appropriate procedures for selection.

There are a million and one things that will need to be done. The

important thing is that we are indicating to the Australian people,

and we're indicating to the world a willingness to help. And

that will make a small contribution to I hope improving the spirits

and improving the sense of hope and relieving the sense of despair

which is no doubt being experienced by these hundreds of thousands

of unfortunate human beings. This is something where a nation of Australia's

strength and wealth, and comparative affluence has an overwhelming

moral obligation to play a part in. That's why we've taken

the decision and it's the right decision. As to all the details

of it, I can't answer your question. I don't know yet. We've

got to work many of those details out. I'm sure with the support

of the Opposition, the goodwill of the Opposition, and I hope the

goodwill of the Australian community and people who support humanitarian

responses that we'll be able to get the job done and get it done

quickly. We obviously need to act as speedily as possible. We know

there's a cost involved. It's a cost worth incurring because

there's a humanitarian response involved.

JOURNALIST:

Mr Howard, can these people be kept under some form of restraint,

I mean, effective captivity so that they don't just scatter in

the community?

PRIME MINISTER:

Well look, initially, Peter, they'll obviously have to go to,

you know, arrival centres around the country. There'll need to

be health checks and so forth. The question of their future movements

away from the initial reception areas, that is something that we're

giving consideration to and we're seeking advice on. You can't

resolve all of these matters in the space of a few hours. You do need

to get advice. They are to be seen as not as part of the normal immigration

programme. And I think if you look at what the Americans are doing

and many of the other countries are doing, I think the Americans are,

so I've been informed, are going to receive them on the Guantanamo

Naval Base in Cuba and also at Guam. They're making special arrangements.

We will give a broadly similar response. The aim of the exercise is

to provide a safe haven. The aim of the exercise is to give to these

people some sense of physical security, sustenance, but not to do

it in a way that relieves the international political pressure on

Milosevic. And one of the criticisms that could be made of the automatic

inclusion of these 4000 people in the normal refugee programme would

be that it would signal that Milosevic had won and that he had succeeded

in expelling these people from their own country. We think this is

the appropriate humanitarian response which falls short of conceding

political ground to Milosevic.

JOURNALIST:

Do you have any concerns, Prime Minister, that it might lead to racial

conflict here in Australia?

PRIME MINISTER:

Well, I don't think it will lead to racial conflict here in Australia.

Australians are humanitarian people. I think, if people look at things

from an Australian national interest point of view, we have decided

to do this because it's the right thing for Australia to do.

We think that this country has a moral obligation to play its part.

I don't believe it will lead to racial conflict. And I can just

say again that Australia respects very much the right of people of

all origins to honour their heritage and preserve their culture. It

never respects the right of people to bring overseas hatreds and bitternesses

into this country wherever those hatreds or bitternesses come from.

JOURNALIST:

Did you discuss today's decision with any other leaders in NATO

or the US?

PRIME MINISTER:

No, no. It is not in response to any request. It is a decision which

has been generated by the Australian Government of its own volition,

according to our assessment of what Australia ought to be doing. I

have not received any request and I'm not aware that Mr Ruddock

or Mr Downer has received any request from any foreign country. We

think it's the right thing for Australia to be doing and that's

why we've taken the decision.

JOURNALIST:

What about the time the Government has [inaudible] of the situation

not being resolved in the Balkan in the three-month period?

PRIME MINISTER:

Well, let's take one thing at a time. I've announced the

decision. I've explained the context in which the decision has

been taken. And what I am saying and what I'm doing, as I understand

it, is no different from the way in which Mr Blair and President Clinton

and others are responding to like questions. I mean, our response

in concept is broadly similar to that of the United States, the United

Kingdom, Germany and a number of other European countries.

JOURNALIST:

What they said about Tiannamen Square when Mr Hawke made his decision

– one thing at a time – but isn't the question that

was on your Immigration Minister's mind yesterday, what happens

after three months or, you know, is there an upper limit to the time

that you permit these people to stay?

PRIME MINISTER:

Well, I am simply not even going to try and answer that question,

not even try. It is altogether too, it's too calculated, that's

too considered and calculated a question. I mean, you've got

a humanitarian crisis. You've got a flood of humanity coming

across borders in the most appalling circumstances and you are a relatively

affluent, very peaceful, very stable, very endowed, very lucky country.

You have a moral obligation to put your hand up and say to the rest

of the world, we are prepared to take our share and to play our part.

There will be problems. There will be difficulties. People will criticise

the decision. After a while people will get impatient and they'll

say you should have done this and you should have done that. I know

all of that and you'll be back with all sorts of questions. But

it is the right thing to do. And we'll deal with three months

in three months time.

JOURNALIST:

In relation to President Milosevic, isn't there a situation where

you intend to repatriate those people and if you can't, then

he has won.

PRIME MINISTER:

Matt, I'm not going to answer a whole series of hypothetical

questions.

JOURNALIST:

You've said there's no upper limit here, but do you have

reason...

PRIME MINISTER:

No upper limit?

JOURNALIST:

Well, you've said that it can be renewed after three months and

presumably Kosovo won't be actually solved within three months...

PRIME MINISTER:

Well, I'm not prepared to speculate about what the situation

will be in three weeks let alone three months. So you may be able

to predict it but I'm not going to try to.

JOURNALIST:

My question was, really, was if Kosovo hasn't been solved to

the point where Albanians can go back and live there, will these people

be shunted off somewhere else down the track?

PRIME MINISTER:

I'm not going to speculate about that. I'm really not. Except

to make the point that the decision that we've taken today can

hardly be categorised as lacking humanity. It's a compassionate,

fair, decent decision. And you can be certain that this Government,

in these matters, will always act in a compassionate, fair and decent

fashion but also with a healthy and firm regard to the Australian

national interest, which is why the whole proposition is conditional

on the passage of that legislation with effect from today which Mr

Beazley has told me this afternoon on the phone the Labor Party will

support.

Thank you.

[ends]

11190