PM Transcripts

Transcripts from the Prime Ministers of Australia

Howard, John

Period of Service: 11/03/1996 - 03/12/2007
Release Date:
01/07/1999
Release Type:
Interview
Transcript ID:
10983
Released by:
  • Howard, John Winston
TRANSCRIPT OF THE PRIME MINISTER THE HON JOHN HOWARD MP RADIO INTERVIEW WITH HOWARD SATTLER (6PR) SUBJECTS: Mr Tim Fischer, the National Party, taxation reform, the Senate, lamb exports, PM's official visit to Japan/USA, Indonesia.

E&OE..................................................................................................

SATTLER:

The Prime Minister joins me now for his regular segment and he is

in our sister station 2UE studio in Canberra. Good morning Prime Minister.

PRIME MINISTER:

Good morning Howard.

SATTLER:

Thanks for joining us. When did Mr Fischer actually ring you and tell

you that he was going to pull the pin?

PRIME MINISTER:

Oh, only a few days ago. He's explained the circumstances of it. We

had our final discussion yesterday. Tim has been a tremendous Deputy

Prime Minister and I am going to miss him. I can't disguise that fact.

He has been a loyal Coalition partner and a very good friend, a wonderful

Trade Minister and just a great personality into the bargain. But

he's decided for the reasons that he has made very plain and he does

have quite young children. He's been in politics for a very long period

of time and he has decided to take a different career path. And whilst

I will miss him terribly I understand and respect that and along with

the rest of the political community and the Australian community more

generally I do wish him and Judy and Harrison and Dominic every happiness

in the future. He's done yeoman service for the country, for the National

Party, for the Coalition Government and very importantly as a Trade

Minister he really has made his mark. I have found as I went around

Asian capitals that everybody knew Tim Fischer...

SATTLER:

And his hat.

PRIME MINISTER:

And his hat and a smile came across their face when you mentioned

him. And he is held in very high regard in the Australian business

community as being a person who is prepared to go out there and punch

hard for Australian business overseas and I thank him for that.

SATTLER:

Did you try and talk him out of it or at least to delay it?

PRIME MINISTER:

Oh look, the sort of conversations that a Prime Minister and a Deputy

Prime Minister have are very intricate, they are very detailed, they

range over a whole lot of subjects and I don't break confidences in

relation to that.

SATTLER:

But is his timing okay with you?

PRIME MINISTER:

Look, his timing is okay with me if it's right for him and his family.

And in the end, individuals in public life know when it's appropriate

for them to go taking all factors into account. And there is no hard

and fast rule for when you go or how long you stay or what age it

is it depends entirely upon each separate set of circumstances, what

your other interests are, what the age of your children might be,

what your health is like. All of those things. How long you have been

around. There's no hard and fast rule, it varies enormously. Tim has

reached a firm decision to go. I am sure it's the right decision for

him because it's a decision that he believes is right for him. And

in the end he's the only person who has got a right to make that judgement.

SATTLER:

Does it cause you to reflect on your own situation, the past and the

future? You have put 25 years of public service in too and I guess

a lot of the time you have had to put that ahead of your family?

PRIME MINISTER:

Well, my family, of course, is older than Tim's family....

SATTLER:

They are now, of course.

PRIME MINISTER:

Yes, and in a way the more challenging years are behind Janette and

I in relation to our children. They are now three adults, we are a

very happy group and I am immensely grateful for that and we are enjoying

their company as young adults and that's a marvellous phase of your

life. I enjoyed their company as young children. We were able to organise

things between ourselves so that even though I was away a lot when

I was at home I did nothing else but devote myself to the children.

We now, I guess, are getting the reward of that because as young adults

we are enjoying their company and it's very stimulating, we are enjoying

that company immensely.

SATTLER:

Yeah but see, Tim Fischer is quitting largely because of the health

condition of one of his children and your wife was quite ill for a

time too. I mean, was there a time when you thought, well, you know

really I have just got to put the family first and maybe it's time

to go?

PRIME MINISTER:

Well, I have been asked that before. Janette was ill three years ago.

Thankfully she has got over that and her health now is very good and

she's very enthusiastic about my continued participation in public

life.

SATTLER:

What indefinitely?

PRIME MINISTER:

Well, nobody stays forever, break it down.

SATTLER:

No.

PRIME MINISTER:

She wouldn't want me to do that. But I said...

SATTLER:

Well, you'd probably like to enjoy your lives together and stop us

hassling you.

PRIME MINISTER:

Well, you never hassle me you just ask hard questions. Howard, I said

at the time of the last election you take it one term at a time. I

have got very good health, I am very lucky and we have reached a stage

in our life where, as I say, our children are young adults. That doesn't

mean to say you don't still have responsibilities and continued intense

interest and devotion and commitment but it's a slightly different

situation than perhaps 15 years ago...

SATTLER:

But do you review your life ahead and say, well okay, I am going to

go to the next election but after that I really am going to have a

think about it?

PRIME MINISTER:

Well, what I say is I do one election at a time when you reach my

age. And I have been re-elected and I am enjoying it. I am still stimulated

by it. I think the Government is achieving a lot and we have got more

to achieve.

SATTLER:

But you have achieved your primary goal and that is tax reform.

PRIME MINISTER:

Oh well, it's an ongoing thing. I have got to bed that down, we've

got business tax coming up. Howard I am still stimulated by it, I

am still energised by it and I still have a lot, I hope, to give to

this country but nobody stays forever.

SATTLER:

No, no, okay. So you will go to the next poll, we can confirm that?

PRIME MINISTER:

Well, we take one election at a time.

SATTLER:

Okay. Now, the new leader has been elected, the new leader of the

National Party, John Anderson, said to be a lot drier than Tim Fischer.

What does that mean?

PRIME MINISTER:

Well, can I first of all congratulate John for being elected leader

and Mark Vaile as Deputy. They'll be an excellent team. I like and

respect them both, they are very intelligent, energetic men. Both

of them understand the needs of the Australian economy and a global

economy as Tim Fischer did. Can I say I don't agree with that, I don't

think to use these rather simplistic expressions of dry or not so

dry. I think Tim, one of Tim's many virtues was that he never gave

in to populism, he always argued that in the long-term interests of

this country, including its rural community, we needed to trade more

successfully and to open markets abroad. And therefore we had a vested

interest greater than most in an open world trading system. Now, John

Anderson...

SATTLER:

It's a pity our American friends don't have the same attitude.

PRIME MINISTER:

Well, this is precisely the argument I put to President Clinton. When

I spoke to him on the phone a few weeks ago I said: Bill, if you take

this restrictive decision on lamb it will go against all of your rhetoric

and it will be used by other countries as an excuse for them to lapse

back into protectionism.

SATTLER:

What did he say?

PRIME MINISTER:

Well, he said he would consider that and we haven't had a decision

yet. I must say, like Tim Fischer, I am not very optimistic as to

what that decision will be. But John Anderson understands the modern

world, we all do and it is in the long-term interests of Australia

that we prize open world markets. We are only 18.5 million people,

we must trade to survive and we must make sure that we are competitive

and that's why we have got a new tax system because our exports will

be cheaper under the new tax system.

SATTLER:

Does that mean you will offer John Anderson a trade portfolio because

I understood he didn't want to take it or Mark Vaile?

PRIME MINISTER:

Well, I will talk to John about the arrangements. That's a matter

of courtesy I owe to him.

SATTLER:

Would you like him to take that.....?

PRIME MINISTER:

Well I will talk to him first before I start saying what I'd

like him to take. He is the newly elected leader of the National Party.

He will on the 20th of July or there abouts become the

Deputy Prime Minister of Australia and I owe him the courtesy of talking

to him first before I start saying who does what amongst National

Party ministers. He has a right to have an input into that as part

of our Coalition arrangement.

SATTLER:

Sure. [Commercial break]. I've got the Prime Minister in our

[inaudible] 2UE studios in Canberra. If you want to give him a call

you can on 9221 1233. He was telling us that he has been speaking

with President Clinton about their attempts to try and protect their

farming fraternity over there and exclude Australian lamb from the

markets over there. Prime Minister, you are due to meet Mr Clinton

what, the week after next is it?

PRIME MINISTER:

Yeah, on the 12th of July. I'm leaving Australia on

Monday to go an official visit to Japan and that will be next week.

And then at the end of next week I'll go onto the United States

and I'll see the President.

SATTLER:

Will you get to him before they make a decision...?

PRIME MINISTER:

Well I don't know. I don't know. I expected a decision about

a week or ten days ago. I still remain basically a bit pessimistic

because in the end on these matters the Americans do have a track

record of listening to domestic pressure. It will be a great shame

if they go against us on this.

SATTLER:

Well what will we do about it?

PRIME MINISTER:

Well you've got to remember we're only 18.5 million people.

SATTLER:

I know, and they know that too.

PRIME MINISTER:

Well I know. But it doesn't alter the fact that if they do the

wrong thing on this it sends a terrible signal to other countries.

I just hope that they will listen to us at least to some degree.

SATTLER:

All right, back to domestic matters. You were clearly delighted to

get the tax reform package including the GST through the Parliament.

But this is not the tax package we voted you into office on. Are we

entitled to feel a little cheated with what we've got?

PRIME MINISTER:

Well it's 85% of what you voted for.

SATTLER:

That's right but.....

PRIME MINISTER:

Well the alternative was to spit the dummy and persevere with the

present system, or to take the public back for another election with

no guarantee that that would deliver 100%. I mean we could.....

SATTLER:

Or that you'd get re-elected.

PRIME MINISTER:

Well of course. I mean there's always...Howard I don't

disguise that in any election there's a danger you're going

to lose. There's a winner and a loser in every election. I don't

think the public wanted another election.

SATTLER:

No well I'm sure they didn't.

PRIME MINISTER:

It wasn't the mail I was getting. The mail I was getting from

people was basically they really wanted, even those who didn't

vote for it, they wanted the package to go through in its original

form. When we found we couldn't do that most people were saying

to me well see if you can negotiate an outcome with the Australian

Democrats which delivers most of what you wanted. You won't get

all of it because you can't expect them to give up everything

that they hold dear. And that's exactly what I did and I found

in negotiating with the Democrats in Senator Lees an intelligent,

straight forward candid woman with whom one could talk and do business,

and we did that.

SATTLER:

Would you like to get rid of the Senate?

PRIME MINISTER:

Oh, well no. I don't think you can get rid of the Senate, it's

part of the Federal compact.

SATTLER:

Well in New Zealand they got rid of the Upper House in their Parliament

and they got the GST through in 2 hours did they.

PRIME MINISTER:

But New Zealand's not a federation. You can't ignore the

history of this country, particularly when I'm talking to a Western

Australian audience. It started with the States and we formed it into

soluble federal commonwealth. We are a nation of course more importantly

than we are individual States. But the deal for federation essentially

was that you had a Senate with equal State representation to more

or less cater for the less populous parts of Australia and you had

a House of Representatives elected on the basis...

SATTLER:

Is it working as it should?

PRIME MINISTER:

Well sometimes it does, sometimes it doesn't. But I deal with

reality. Change of that kind is very difficult in this country and

I'm not sure that the Australian public mind the current arrangement.

I think it waxes and wanes a bit. I'm certainly not proposing

any radical changes in that area.

SATTLER:

On the goods and services tax, do you feel sympathy for small mixed

retail businesses who are saying they're going to be saddled

with a paper and financial nightmare trying to comply with a GST.

PRIME MINISTER:

I don't believe it will be as bad as some are suggesting and

we are going to put a lot of resources in the way of making sure it

isn't. So the answer is, I think by the time all the systems

are ready for its introduction in a year's time then it won't

be anything like what people suggest and I suspect it will be like

New Zealand. After it had been in place for a few weeks people have

said, gee, what was all the fuss about.

SATTLER:

Yeah, but what help are you going to give those people?

PRIME MINISTER:

A lot. We're putting $500 million aside for small businesses

and others to help with the implementation of the GST. And we are

going to conduct a very extensive education campaign and we're

going to adopt a very practical approach to compliance in relation

to those businesses that are essentially selling items that are both

subject to and exempt from the GST.

SATTLER:

Do you think there'll be much rorting or attempted rorting?

PRIME MINISTER:

Well, there's always some of that no matter what system you have

but the great beauty of a GST is that it's harder to rort than

the present system.

SATTLER:

Yeah, no doubt about that. All right, but logically some of the eating

out establishments will suffer once they have to...

PRIME MINISTER:

No, not necessarily.

SATTLER:

Why?

PRIME MINISTER:

Well, because people will have more money in their pocket to buy their

restaurant meals. They will have more money in their pocket. You see,

everybody's in front unless you're a crook because there

are personal tax cuts. And if you watch my Address to the Nation tonight

I'll explain it in more detail.

SATTLER:

I'll watch with bated breath. I'll be riveted to it.

PRIME MINISTER:

Yeah, I'm sure you will.

SATTLER:

How do you think it's going to rate?

PRIME MINISTER:

I don't know. I mean, these things, I mean, you've...

SATTLER:

You've got to do it.

PRIME MINISTER:

Well, no, it's important. It's important. I don't think

I'll quite be able to match Sea Change though.

SATTLER:

Or the tennis.

PRI

10983